15A / 15 & 13 S Menantic Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964 (MLS # 842673)

For the first time in over a century, this extraordinary collection of generationally owned properties is being offered together as a singular and rare opportunity. Nestled along the serene and picturesque Menantic Creek, these three separate parcels combined total 4.9 acres, which have been combined into one sale, presenting an unrivaled waterfront retreat. The Menantic Creek, known as Hurricane Hole for boat protection during storms, offers boating access to both the North and South Forks and a short run to Montauk. For the boating enthusiast, this offering includes a 100-foot stationary dock, complete with a 6-foot-wide walkway with a bench, as well as a 12-foot plastic ramp leading to a 30x6 ft. floating dock with three anchor pilings. Two moorings on the creek are also available, pending reapplication. At the heart of this offering is 15A Menantic Road, a legally designated two-family residence with a breathtaking 3,944 square feet of meticulously renovated living space. This refined home features five bedrooms, 4 plus 2 1/2 baths, and a 483-square-foot garage, all thoughtfully designed to maximize the stunning creek views. Taxes: $12,206.00 Adjacent to this residence is 15 Menantic Road, a pristine and vacant 1.3-acre parcel, offering endless potential to further enhance this exceptional estate. Taxes: $4,325.00 Completing the trio is 13 Menantic Road, a charming 1930s bungalow with two bedrooms and one bath set on 1.47 acres and a brand new two story 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home with attached two car garage in the final stages of completion. Taxes: $8,521.00 What truly sets this estate apart is its extraordinary arboretum-like setting, adorned with a curated collection of rare and mature specimen trees, including Copper Beech, Southern Magnolia, White Birch, Monkey Puzzle, Dawn Redwoods, Linden, Osage Orange, Red Japanese Maple, and Dogwood. The natural beauty of this land is simply unparalleled. This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to own a waterfront compound with limitless potential"”a legal multi-family residence, a historic bungalow, a new construction home and an untouched parcel"”all in one of the most coveted locations. A truly rare find for the discerning buyer seeking exclusivity, natural beauty, and unparalleled waterfront living.

Last Updated	5/9/2025	Year Built	1983
Garage Spaces	2.0	County	Suffolk

SCHOOLS

Elementary School	Contact Agent
Jr. High School	Shelter Island School
High School	Shelter Island School

Additional Details

AIR	Central Air
AIR CONDITIONING	Yes
APPLIANCES	Convection Oven, Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Cooktop, Electric Oven, Electric Water Heater, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer
BASEMENT	Partially Finished, Storage Space
EXTERIOR	Basketball Court, Boat Slip, Dog Run, Garden, Playground, Rain Gutters
FIREPLACE	Yes
GARAGE	Yes
HEAT	Electric
INTERIOR	Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer
LOT	2.9 acre(s)
LOT DESCRIPTION	Back Yard, Cleared, Front Yard, Garden, Level
PARKING	Driveway, Garage, Shared Driveway
SEWER	Cesspool
STORIES	2
STYLE	Contemporary
TAXES	25052
UTILITIES	Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected
VIEW	Yes
VIEW DESCRIPTION	Water
WATER	Public, Private, Well
WATERFRONT DESCRIPTION	Creek

Location

 

Contact us about this Property

---